Why investment and ambition aren’t closing the gap, and what will
Six million fewer people give to UK charities than a decade ago, and giving fell 9% in a single year. Yet charities have never been more committed to the supporter experience. 94% call it a top priority and 92% are investing more. Belief in charities is holding too. 54% of supporters say charities do essential good that wouldn’t happen otherwise. So why isn’t the gap closing?
Last year we showed the distance between what supporters need and what charities deliver, and the actions any charity can take to build resilient relationships. This year we went a level deeper to find out why that gap persists when the sector is investing more than ever in the supporter experience. We uncover what supporters need from an experience, what’s really pushing them away, and what gets in the way behind the scenes. Closing the gap still remains one of the biggest opportunities for the sector to overcome today’s turbulent challenges.
Mind the Engagement Gap 2026 draws on new research with 1,626 UK charity supporters and 302 senior charity leaders, plus interviews with leaders at Animals Asia, CALM, Diabetes UK, Macmillan Cancer Support, Prostate Cancer UK and WWF-UK.
In this whitepaper, you’ll discover:
- Why charities’ investment in their own teams and supporter experience won’t close the gap alone: 85% of supporters aren’t growing their giving, and a third barely notice or actively avoid what charities send.
- The four things supporters need from an experience: control, honesty and relevance, respect, and recognition. Where charities fall short on each, and what action to take taking inspiration from who's doing this well in both the non profit and commercial sector customer experience from the likes of Netflix and Pinterest.
- The Connected Framework: how the experience supporters see on the frontstage is made by five layers backstage.
- What’s really pushing supporters away: the top three reasons supporters consider stopping are guilt-heavy or pushy messaging (34%), how much goes on running costs (33%) and being asked for more too often (30%).
- Where to start and how to make change stick: practical engagement and retention strategies for every layer, from one “golden question” and a proper preference centre to contact ceilings and agentic decisioning.
- How organisations like WWF-UK, RNIB, Animals Asia, Concern Worldwide and Shelter are closing the gap, and how to build the case for investment with your board.
Ready to close the gap?
Whether you’re shaping a supporter, member or audience engagement strategy, download the full whitepaper for the complete research, framework and recommendations.
Download the full whitepaper for the complete insight and action plan.
The four things supporters need
Where
Control
Supporters want to decide how they hear from you, what they hear about and how they give. 81% rate this as important, yet only 22% of charities hold each supporter’s preferences.
What
Honesty and relevance
Supporters want to see where their money goes and what it achieved, and to hear about the things they care about. One in five (21%) were unsure of their impact the last time they gave, and 59% say it’s important to be contacted only about things relevant to them.
When
Respect
Supporters expect to be asked, but at the right moment. 80% say not being pushed for more before they’re ready is important, and 30% have considered stopping because they were asked too often.
Who
Recognition
Supporters want to be treated as people, not donors to be processed. Fewer than half (47%) felt appreciated after their last gift, and only 30% of charities record why each supporter gives.
Behind every one of these sit the same five layers:
- Shared culture
- People and process
- Using data
- Tech and systems
- Governance and policies
That’s why progress at all means progress across all.

Making change across every layer
WWF-UK’s supporters were getting a fragmented experience, designed around products rather than their needs. Working with manifesto, WWF mapped every team, audience, system and process across the supporter journey and turned it into one connected change programme with measurable milestones for every layer. The board could see the whole picture, and committed to a three-to-four-year investment programme.
“We now have a core list of top priority projects across the whole organisation, that need shared resources and will have shared, measurable outcomes.” Ruth Doyle, Director of Supporter Experience, WWF-UK
Read the full case study and find more examples from RNIB, Animals Asia, Concern Worldwide, Shelter and ShareTheMeal in the full report.
Ready to turn ambition into action?
manifesto is the digital experience agency for changemakers. We bring customer experience consulting, customer journey mapping and digital engagement strategy to purpose-led organisations. Here are two ways we can help you start.
See where you are today
We’ll take your teams through our Experience Gap Maturity model, where every team scores the same fundamentals of the supporter experience, so you can see where your layers line up and where they pull apart.
Build the case for change
Share some data about your organisation and we’ll use our Opportunity Calculator to show what a change programme could be worth in team efficiency, cost savings and income, so you can show your board why it’s worth the investment.
Get in touch
Supporters who feel known, valued and connected give more and stay longer. Wherever you are today, you can get there. Let’s build the experiences that make it happen
See where you are today
We’ll take your teams through our Experience Gap Maturity model, where every team scores the same fundamentals of the supporter experience, so you can see where your layers line up and where they pull apart.
Build the case for change
Share some data about your organisation and we’ll use our Opportunity Calculator to show what a change programme could be worth in team efficiency, cost savings and income, so you can show your board why it’s worth the investment.
Get in touch
Supporters who feel known, valued and connected give more and stay longer. Wherever you are today, you can get there. Let’s build the experiences that make it happen
When supporters feel known, valued and connected, they give more and stay longer. Let’s build the experiences that make it happen. Talk to us: [email protected]